TWO
CONTRASTING
17th and 18th
CENTURY
APPROACHES
to SPIRITUALITY
and MORAL
THEOLOGY
IGNATIAN Mental visualization of Biblical Scenes Step-by-step reflection leading to discernment Examen concerning sin required throughout life
|
Non-discursive meditation Resting in the presence of God Sin “impossible” in highest stages [Molinos condemned by Innocent XI in Coelestis Pastor - 19 Nov. 1687]
|
PROBABILISM Penitents given “benefit of the doubt” Lesser-held opinion may nonetheless be “probable” [condemned by Pope Alexander VII (1666, 1667) and more forcefully by Pope Innocent XI (1679)]
|
MORAL RIGORISM Strict ethical standards and requirement of repentance/penance: Confessor acts solely on what is certain – always in favor of precept of law Strict rigorism (“tutiorism” condemned by Pope Alexander VIII in 1690 (Denzinger 2303)
|
FREEDOM
The soul cooperates with God |
PREDESTINATION
God has predestined both the elect
and the damned. (Double predestination condemned in Trent Decree on Justification, canons 15 and 17) |
ENGAGEMENT Missionary Activity Education |
WITHDRAWAL
|
This Webpage was created for a workshop held at Saint Andrew's Abbey, Valyermo, California in 2014